Unite UK is committed to upholding and promoting the rights of lesbian, gay, and bisexual (LGB) individuals. The freedom to love whomever one chooses, without fear of discrimination or persecution, is a fundamental pillar of a modern, liberal democracy. The UK has made significant progress in recognising and protecting the rights of LGB individuals, but challenges remain.

​

However, it is critical to differentiate LGB rights from the broader transgender movement. While we fully support the rights of individuals to express their identities freely, we believe the conflation of LGB and transgender issues has, in some cases, undermined the core objectives of LGB advocacy. This paper outlines the importance of defending LGB rights while ensuring that these issues remain distinct from gender ideology.

 

The Right to Love: Defending LGB Rights

The legal and societal advances in LGB rights over the past few decades have been transformative. From the decriminalisation of homosexuality to the legalisation of same-sex marriage, the UK has set a strong precedent for LGB acceptance and equality. However, there is still work to be done.

• Ensuring Freedom of Expression: LGB individuals must be able to express their relationships and identities without fear of hostility or censorship.

• Defending Sex-Based Attraction: The right of lesbians and gay men to be exclusively attracted to the same sex must be upheld without coercion to accept individuals based on gender identity rather than biological sex.

• Strengthening Legal Protections: Hate crimes against LGB individuals should continue to be addressed with firm legal protections to ensure public safety.

• International Advocacy: The UK must remain a vocal advocate for LGB rights globally, particularly in countries where same-sex relationships are still criminalised or punishable by death.

​

The Distinction Between LGB and Transgender Issues

While LGB rights are rooted in sexual orientation—the immutable fact of who someone is attracted to—transgender issues revolve around gender identity, a more fluid and subjective concept. The failure to differentiate these two movements has led to tensions within the LGB community, particularly among lesbians and gay men.

• Sex-Based Attraction vs. Gender Identity: Many LGB individuals have expressed concern that the transgender movement pressures them to accept partners based on gender identity rather than biological sex. Lesbians, for example, are sometimes accused of being ‘transphobic’ for not being attracted to trans women (biological males who identify as women). This undermines the fundamental concept of same-sex attraction.

• Impact on Young LGB People: There is growing evidence that some young people who might naturally come to identify as LGB are instead being encouraged to see themselves as transgender due to gender non-conforming behaviours. Encouraging children to transition rather than embracing their sexual orientation can have long-term consequences, including medical interventions that may not be necessary.

• Erosion of LGB Spaces: Many organisations originally founded to support LGB individuals have shifted their focus towards transgender activism, often at the expense of issues specific to same-sex attraction. This has led to concerns that the core advocacy for LGB individuals is being neglected.

 

Preserving Safe Spaces for LGB Individuals

In recent years, traditional LGB spaces have been affected by the inclusion of gender identity-focused policies. It is crucial to ensure that LGB individuals retain spaces where they can discuss their experiences without pressure to conform to ideological beliefs about gender.

• Lesbian and Gay Dating Spaces: LGB dating spaces should be protected from ideological pressure that demands they include individuals who do not fit the criteria of same-sex attraction.

• LGB Youth Support: Support groups for LGB young people should focus on helping them understand and accept their sexual orientation rather than encouraging medical transition as a response to gender non-conformity.

• Revitalising LGB Advocacy Groups: More organisations should focus exclusively on LGB rights rather than merging with gender identity activism, which often shifts priorities away from same-sex attraction.

 

Policy Recommendations

To strengthen and protect the rights of LGB individuals while maintaining a clear distinction from transgender issues, Unite UK proposes the following policy initiatives:

• Reaffirm Legal Protections for LGB People: Ensure that anti-discrimination laws continue to robustly protect individuals based on sexual orientation.

• Prevent Ideological Pressure on LGB People: Address instances where lesbians and gay men are pressured to redefine their sexual preferences to include trans individuals.

• Support LGB-Exclusive Spaces: Encourage the creation and protection of spaces and events that cater specifically to LGB individuals without fear of ideological interference.

• Ensure Accurate Data Collection: Reinstate separate categories for sexual orientation and gender identity in official statistics to ensure LGB-specific issues are properly recognised and addressed.

• Promote Honest Conversations About Gender and Sexuality: Encourage open, respectful discussions about the differences between sexual orientation and gender identity without accusations of bigotry or discrimination.

 

Conclusion

Unite UK stands firmly in support of LGB rights, defending the right to love freely and without discrimination. However, we believe it is essential to distinguish these rights from transgender issues, ensuring that the fight for same-sex attraction does not become diluted or compromised by ideological shifts. By reaffirming LGB rights as a distinct and critical issue, we can continue to champion equality while ensuring that LGB individuals are not erased in the broader discourse on gender identity.

The right to love whomever you choose is a fundamental principle that must be protected. Unite UK will continue to stand for the rights of LGB individuals and work to ensure that these rights remain at the forefront of public policy and social advocacy.